And here I was, worrying about what might be 'revealed' of possible sex abuses by priests when Cardinal Ratzinger was Archbishop of Munich-Freising! Now, the scandal has somehow touched his brother! Which is one way for the media - no matter how far-fetched - to associate the Pope himself directly with these abuses
online
reports today (translated):
BERLIN - The Bishop of Regensburg has admitted that sexual abuses took place in the environment of the Regensburg boys' choir known as the Domspatzen at the time when they were under the musical direction of Mons. Georg Ratzinger, brother of Pope Benedict XVI. The Bishop wrote about this in a letter to aggrieved parents published on his site.
This time, Repubblica did what
dpa was guilty of doing yesterday, but worse: a gross misrepresentation of what Bishop Gerhard Mueller has on his site, in order to focus attention on Mons. Ratzinger who is not even mentioned in this primary source. Compare the
Repubblica report to the following information that I gleaned from the diocesan report on its website. It is rather lengthy, so I won't translate, but in effect, it says the ff:
In the past several weeks, reports have been received of incidents, infringements as well as abuses committed by priests in the Diocese of Regensburg, most of them dating to the 1960s and early 1970s (more specifically, according to German news reports, from 1958-1973).
In view of this, the Diocese is calling on all victims to report the incidents to the diocese, even as it is undertaking a systematic inquiry to establish what abuses were committed, who were the offenders, and who were the victims, with the aid of contemporaneous press reports as well as any records in the diocese, interviews with witnesses, etc.
The diocese will follow three objectives in its efforts: to give justice and aid to the victims; to press criminal and canonical action against the offenders; and to prevent any further incidents.
It goes on to list the cases that have been investigated so far. Of the four named,
only one had anything to do with the Domspatzen - a priest who was the director of the Domspatzen boarding school from January-August of 1959
before Mons. Ratzinger came to Regensburg , but
the accusations against him date to 1969-1971 when he was employed by the diocese itself, and no longer had anything to do with the Domspatzen. He was later reassigned to a seminary in Weiden, which retired him at age 58. He is deceased now.
A second case involves a priest who was the prefect of the Regensburg Musikgymnasium [a 'regular' specialized high school, not having to do with the Domspatzen]* from 1953-1958, when he was dismissed for having been caught in incidents with two of his wards. He was tried and sentenced to two years in jail. *
[Correction: It appears from a couple of German news reports I've read that the Regensburger Musikgymnasium is the high school to which the Dompstaen boarding school is attached.]
However, the report also mentions two victim reports received by the diocesan office of alleged
abuse in the 1960s attributed to the staff in charge of the Domspatzen. Apparently, not enough information has been gathered about these two cases yet.
Mons. Georg Ratzinger was musical director of the Domspatzen from 1964-1994.
P.S. It turns out that the letter attributed by the first stories to Bishop Mueller was not from him but from the current music director of the choir. No wonder I could not find it on the diocesan site. In any case, the diocesan report is the most reliable account of what is known so far.
From the above, you can see how misleading and unfair the Repubblica account of Mueller's letter is! I can already see the headlines by Church-bashing, Pope-hating editors who will say "Sexual abuses on Regensburg choirboys when Pope's brother was in charge" - based on the Repubblica account alone!
P.S.
online now has a story on this, and the headline is not far from what I thought:
Pedophile priest scandal in Germany
in the choir directed by the Pope's brother -
The bishop of Regensburg admits it
with a lead paragraph substantially similar to, and therefore as deliberately misleading as Repubblica's. The article mentions some of the facts I summarized above, but its last paragraph also has this information:
THE REPLY OF GEORG RATZINGER - The brother of Pope Benedict XVI said in an interview today with Bavarian radio Bayerischen Rundfunk that he had no knowledge of any sexual abuses committed in the environment of the Regensburg boys' choir when he was the director.
Now I have to see what I can find in the German media... Meanwhile, there has been a reaction from the Vatican, reported by the Italian news agency
The first part is almost identical to the Corriere story, but brings up Mons. Ratzinger's statement to the lead paragraph, with the added detail that the Monsignor said in effect
[with his usual solid common sense] that since he has no knowledge of any of this, journalists should direct all questions to the Diocese of Regensburg.
The last paragraph reports the Vatican reaction:
The Vatican will 'not intervene' in the question of sexual abuses reportedly committed against the Regensburg boys' choir when it was under the direction of the Pope's brother.
The Vatican Press office said newsmen can refer to the statements from the Diocese of Regensburg and Mons. Ratzinger himself.
"The Holy See is taking the entire matter of pedophile scandals involving priests in Germany very seriously," said the deputy press director, Fr. Ciro Benedettini, but he said the Vatican will not intervene directly in the Regensburg cases. [Which is as it should be - it's the responsibility of the local bishop and the superiors of any religious orders that may have had priest offenders.]
I expect the German media will now go all-out to find the ex-Domspatz who claimed he was a victim, or find another victim or someone who knows of victims during his time in the choir, especially when it was under Mons. Ratzinger! Maybe Der Spiegel already has one....Let us pray for Mons. Georg, that he may not have to deal with these problems at all! Fortunately, he and his brother have each other to turn to in trying times. God bless them!
The AP has a fairly subdued brief report that still manages to be tendentious, and with a rather convoluted headline that is factually wrong - it's not the choir that's facing the abuse claims!
Pope's brother's choir
faces abuse claims
BERLIN, March 5 (AP) – The Regensburg Diocese says a former member claims he was abused while singing with Germany's leading Roman Catholic boys' choir that was led for 30 years by the brother of Pope Benedict XVI.
The Diocese said in a statement Friday that one former member of the Regensburger Domspatzen claimed priests abused him in the early 1960s. They did not elaborate on the abuse, but said more allegations were expected.
[That would be one of the two cases reported to the diocese but still lacking concrete data, that I cited in my 'summary. The problem with this AP report is that it makes it appear that this complaint was the only content of the diocesan statement and completely ignores the universal overview that it gives of the diocesan approach to the problem and of the concrete cases that can be cited so far.]
In an ever-widening scandal, at least 170 people have alleged they were sexually or physically abused by priests while students at several Catholic high schools across Germany.
The Pope's brother, Georg Ratzinger, led the choir from 1964 to 1994. He told public radio Bayerischer Rundfunk on Friday he did not know of any abuse cases at the choir.
And from dpa - an erroneous headline, to begin with. Mons. Ratzinger was musical director of the choir. He had nothing to do with the Domspatzen's boarding school, and certainly did not teach there, much less head it, as the lead paragraph says! How can dpa, a German news agency, get elementary facts so wrong?
School where Pope's brother taught
is linked to sex abuse
Hamburg, March 5 (dpa) - A boarding school in Germany which was
once headed by Georg Ratzinger, the brother of Pope Benedict XVI, says it is checking out a claim that a teacher committed sex abuse in the early 1960s.
The Regensburger Domspatzen School, which educates the children who sing in one of Germany's top boys' choirs, said it was shocked to discover a newspaper clipping from the 1950s showing that a man who directed the boarding department was convicted of sex abuse.
[The story does not state that the conviction was for offenses committed after the priest had left the Regensburg boarding school!]
The school is under the control of the director of music at Regensburg Cathedral in Germany.
[Can that be true???? How can a musical director, who has more than enough of a job to fill, also be in charge of the boarding school???? Also, the diocesan statement made clear that there is a separate position for director of the boarding school.]
The priest who held that post till 1963 was Theobald Schrems, followed by Georg Ratzinger from 1964 to 1994.
Ratzinger, 86, told Bavarian radio in Regensburg on Friday he was not aware of any cases of sex abuse at the school and declined further comment.
In a letter to former pupils published on its website, the cathedral director of music, Roland Buechner, said the school was trying to make contact with a man who has told German newspapers he suffered sexual abuse while he was a pupil at
the start of the 1960s.
[If it took place before 1964, then clearly Mons. Ratzinger is completely out of the picture, but if it happened when he already was in Regensburg, how can he be expected to know if sexual abuses were committed if no complaints wre made at the time?]
The Catholic Church has come under heavy attack in Germany in recent weeks over allegations that senior officials failed to keep a small number of convicted paedophiles away from children right up to the 1980s.
Nationwide, about 150 people have contacted church-appointed lawyers, describing how they were abused at various church schools. Almost all the cases occurred too long ago to be prosecuted now.
The German bishops are now reviewing whether their 2002 guideline on sex abuse is strong enough. It says that bishops do not need to report borderline cases to police, but should only suggest to offenders that they turn themselves in.
I am thankful I can read German and could go to the original source. Otherwise I would have been at the mercy of the misrepresentations - by commission and omission - in the news reports I have seen so far about this subject!
Additional data thanks to Lella's scouts who have checked out at least four German newspapers:
It appears that the spokesman for the Regensburg diocese gave a news conference Thursday afternoon to talk about the cases described in the diocesan website.
None of the four German newspapers checked out did as the Italians and Anglophone media have - to place the Ratzinger name or the Pope's in their headlines on this story. Examples:
Dozens of victims, a dozen abusers - from the very leftwing
FAZ (which had amost insulting headline of Benedict's election in 2005), whose lead for the story was the news conference given by the monks of Ettal Abbey in Bavaria, followed by the Regensburg report.
Scandal reaches the Regensburg Domspatzen - from the tabloid BILD, which mentions Mons. Ratzinger only in the last paragraph.
Abuses committed even in the Regensburg boys choir - from
Sueddeutsche Zeitung, the leftist but very influential Munich newspaper which has never been sympathetic to Archbishop/Cardinal/Pope Ratzinger.
Sexual abuse in the Catholic Church: Complaints even among the Regensburg Domspatzen - from
Der Spiegel, another non-sympathizer.
I salute them all for their well-placed discretion, fairness and elementary decency this time. I hope it lasts! And may these virtues be more widely observed in the media today, where people not sympathetic to the respective editors are generally tried/convicted/sentenced by headline and insinuation, or otherwise besmirched by flagrant attempts at insinuating guilt by association.
Reuters has this report - belated in relation to AP and dpa - but for some reason, it has scaled up the numbers for Regensburg or purposely used the other abuse cases mentioned by the Regensburg diocese website (a couple of them limited to corporal punishment and not necessarily sexual abuse) to suggest they all had to do with sexual abuse of members of the boys' choir!
Abuse cases found at
renowned German Catholic choir
BERLIN, March 5 (Reuters) – A Catholic Church choir once led by the brother of Pope Benedict has learned of several cases of priests abusing boys between 1958 and 1973, the diocese of Regensburg in southern Germany said Friday.
Rev Georg Ratzinger, who led the choir from 1964 to 1994, told Bavarian Radio he knew nothing of the cases, the latest in a series of such charges harming the Church's image in Germany.
Pope Benedict, the former Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, taught theology at the University of Regensburg from 1969 to 1977.
The diocese said in a statement that one priest abused two boys sexually in 1958 and was sentenced to two years in jail. Another clergyman served 11 months in jail in 1971 for abuse.
It mentioned three men who claimed to have suffered sexual abuse as well as excessive beatings and humiliation in the early 1960s by several unnamed teachers while they were at boarding schools connected to the choir.
The "Regensburger Domspatzen" (Regensburg Cathedral Sparrows) is the official choir for the diocese that traces its roots back to the year 975. Apart from its work at the cathedral, it regularly performs on tours of Germany and abroad.
The diocese said several people had come forward with charges of abuse because of recent media reports about other cases elsewhere in Germany. It did not give a precise number.
It has employed a lawyer to further clarify past incidents and identify more victims. The diocese set up a five-person panel on sexual abuse in 2008 to assist victims.
"Sexual abuse is contrary to the mission of the church ... People with pedophile fixations can no longer be employed in the service of the church," it said in the statement.
Archbishop Robert Zollitsch, head of the German Bishops Conference, apologized last month for sexual abuse of children by Catholic priests after over 100 such cases were reported in Jesuit boarding schools around the country.
****************
About the latter: A report today says Mons. Zollitsch will be meeting with Pope Benedict on Monday, March 12. He announced this last week at the end of the German bishops' annual assembly, saying it is his usual post-assembly mwwting with the Pope, only this time, they have the sex abuse brouhaha to discuss as well.
I have reservations about continuing to use the word 'scandal' for these episodes. It is a highly judgmental word intended to connote the worst in the mind of the reader or listener. Sexual offenses committed by priests in an environment that provides them with motive, means and opportunity should not be surprising because priests are human, and some are bound to err or commit abuses. Those who do sin this way obviously have betrayed their calling to be 'alter Christus' and must be made to answer for their offenses/crimes.
At the same time, sexual abuse of minors is by no means limited to priests (statistically, most such abusers are parents, relatives or friends of tthe victim), nor to Catholic priests (just that the media is not much interested in reporting sexual offenses by anyone other than Catholic priests).
What is truly scandalous is when the priest-offenders' superiors cover up for them, tolerate them, and the offender goes on to victimize dozens, if not hundreds, of minors.
Completing the reports filed by the major Anglophone news services on what I call the 'new Regensburg ruckus' aka 'much media ado about nothing' aka 'anything to take down the Pope a notch- or more':
More abuse allegations rock
German Catholic Church
BERLIN, March 5 (AFP) - A sexual abuse scandal rocking Germany’s Catholic Church widened on Friday to include a thousand-year-old boys’ choir led for three decades by Pope Benedict XVI’s brother.
A report into alleged abuse at a monastic school in Ettal, meanwhile, said that minors “were massively abused over decades, sexually, physically and psychologically” by several monks in the past.
The famed Domspatzen (Cathedral Sparrows) choir in the southern city of Regensburg, founded in 975, acknowledged in a “letter to parents” published on its website that a child had been abused in the 1950s.
“To our knowledge the boarding school principal at the time was tried and convicted. He has since died,” the choir said.
It also said a former choir member in the 1960s had recently told a paper that he had been sexually molested. An ombudswoman from the local bishopric, Birgit Boehm, has attempted to contact the man.
“At this point it is not clear whether the alleged abuse occurred in our institution or the Etterzhausen preschool,” it said. “The Foundation Regensburg Domspatzen has to date no other evidence of sexual abuse” but pledged to follow up on any further accusations.
“For this reason we ask all who have learned of sexual abuse of minors in our institution by clerics or other church staff, or are victims themselves, to report to a member of the board” or Boehm.
However a spokesman for the Regensburg bishopric, Clemens Neck, told AFP that it had further “information about alleged abuse between 1958 and 1973.”
“We plan to investigate with total transparency,” Neck said.
Two former members of staff at the Domspatzen, which includes a boarding school and a music college, were previously jailed for abuse, and both died in 1984, Neck said.
One of them was the deputy director, Friedrich Z., a former religious studies teacher hired in 1953 and expelled five years later from the musical college.
He was given a two-year jail term before going to work in a convent in Switzerland between 1961 and 1982.
“We do not know what kind of abuse there was, nor whether there were other victims after his conviction. This is being looked into,” Neck said, declining to give further details.
The second man, a former director of the boarding school for Domspatzen choirboys, was “according to our research, jailed for 11 years in 1971 for abuse committed before May 30, 1969,” Neck said.
“We don’t know what happened after his release.”
The Pope’s brother, 86-year-old Georg Ratzinger, led the Domspatzen between 1964 and 1993. He has not been accused of abuse.
In addition to singing in Regensburg’s cathedral, the Domspatzen also go on tour and in 2009 they performed in the Sistine Chapel in Rome in celebrations for Ratzinger’s 85th birthday.
The latest revelations come days after the German Episcopal Conference put Stephan Ackermann, bishop of the western city of Trier, in charge of probing sexual exploitation of children at a number of Catholic institutions in the country.
The chairman of the Conference, Robert Zollitsch, is to meet with the pope March 12 at the Vatican to discuss the cases.
The scandal in Germany broke in January when an elite Jesuit school in Berlin admitted the systematic sexual abuse of its pupils by two Roman Catholic priests in the 1970s and 1980s. Last month two priests and a college rector resigned over abuse cases.
An independent investigator hired by the Jesuit order said that so far around 120 people had come forward alleging abuse.
[Modificato da TERESA BENEDETTA 06/03/2010 14:15]