One day late, but an acknowledgment nonetheless from AP of the Holy Father's history-making participation in a commercial TV program yesterday.... I have left the headline as is, which is perplexing, to say the least, since it bears no relation at all to what the report says, nor for that matter, to what the Pope said...
Multimedia allows Pope to put
modern spin on Good Friday
by Nicole Winfield
VATICAN CITY, April 23 (AP) - Pope Benedict XVI consoled a 7-year-old Japanese girl, reassured a mother about her ailing son's soul and advised a Muslim woman that dialogue was the way to peace in Ivory Coast.
In a push to engage the world online, the Pontiff fielded their questions during an unusual Good Friday appearance on Italian TV. It was hardly a casual or spontaneous chat: Seven questions were selected from thousands that poured in via RAI television's website, and Benedict recorded his answers last week.
He seemed a bit stiff, sitting all alone in a big white chair behind his desk inside the Apostolic Palace as an unseen interviewer read out the letters to him.
But the teacher and pastor in the 84-year-old Benedict came through as he fielded the questions, which all dealt with suffering and Jesus' death, which Christians recall on Good Friday, and his resurrection, celebrated on Easter Sunday.
The first question came from young Elena, who asked the Pope why she felt so afraid after Japan's earthquake shook her house and killed so many children.
"Why do children have to be so sad?" the girl asked. "I'm asking the Pope, who speaks with God, to explain it to me."
Speaking simply as if Elena were right there, Benedict responded that he too wondered why so many innocent people suffer, but that she should take heart in knowing that Jesus had suffered, too.
"You can be sure that in the world, in the universe, there are many people who are with you, thinking of you, doing what they can for you to help you," Benedict said. "Be assured, we are with you, with all the Japanese children who are suffering."
He then turned to a question from an Italian mother, Maria Teresa, who worried about her son, Francesco, who has been in a vegetative state since Easter 2009. She asked if Francesco's soul still remained.
"He feels the presence of love," Benedict told her, praising her for keeping her vigil as a "true act of love.
"I encourage you, therefore, to carry on, to know that you are giving a great service to humanity with this sign of faith, with this sign of respect for life, with this love for a wounded body and a suffering soul," he said.
Monsignor Paul Tighe, the No. 2 in the Vatican's social communications office, said the decision to have the Pope participate in the televised event stemmed from the realization that Benedict must engage more with the public to ensure his message is received.
"This is a very simple beginning of what you could call inter-activity," Tighe said in a recent interview. "It's launching something new for us."
In the past, Benedict has taken pre-selected questions from carefully chosen Catholics, responding live in St. Peter's Square, such as when he meets annually with university students. He also regularly answers questions submitted beforehand by journalists when flying to foreign countries and has fielded questions from groups of priests.
But the Good Friday session was the first time he had taken questions from the general public - and not necessarily even the Catholic public.
"The advantage of this is it opens up the possibility to people who couldn't hope or aspire to having a direct meeting with the Pope, but through the Internet can put their questions there," Tighe said.
That was certainly the case for Bintu, a Muslim woman who greeted the Pope in Arabic and asked him in French for his advice on bringing peace to Ivory Coast, which has been wracked by political violence.
"How many innocents have lost their lives!" she said. "How many mothers and how many children traumatized!"
Benedict told her he was grieved that he could do so little, saying he had tasked the head of the Vatican's justice and peace office, Cardinal Peter Kodwo Turkson, to try to mediate between the country's opposing factions.
"The only path is to renounce violence, to begin anew with dialogue, with the attempt to find peace together, with a new concern for one another, a new willingness to be open to one another," the Pontiff said.
The best account I have seen of the program is by Frederic Mounier, writing for La Croix, who does not only report the Q&A itself, but also the 'side show' that came between each of the seven Q&As, which were presented one by one, then commented uon by studio guests and supplemented with man-on-the-street interviews. It's lengthy but maybe I will translate it for the record,. I now see more clearly what Riccardo Cascioli of Bussola objected to - objections shared by Andrea Tornielli (to be translated) and a couple of other Italian commentators.
It obviously was not the best format in many ways, but it did take place, it was well publicized, and I hope, well-watched. Other than RAI-1, the Italian bishops' TV 2000 and Sky-TV, it was also made available on Eurovision by CTV.
It should provide valuable lessons for what I hope will be a similar program - say once a month - of Q&A qith the Pope, but without the 'talk show' accessories, or at least, better thought-out features that support the Pope's catecheses and do not drown them out.